Many times we have asked about the degree of validity of a claim. Can we sum up the essence of a theory in a particular statement? We realize something about a point of theory, but relegating obviously other parts of the same into the background.
This occurs with the Anthropic Principle, we can not sum up the essence of the theory of the selection of observers without neglecting many other important points. Because of this, the conclusions drawn are not always the right ones, because getting requires greater specialization.
To draw the right conclusions we make in the most appropriate for the purposes of the selection theory of observers:
• The reference system is a system automuestral. We consider our position in the universe is suitable for observation, given that it no privileged reference systems on a large scale.
· We have two uncertainties due to our own perceptual boundaries and natural boundaries (uncertainty principle), not knowing our place in the universe, since there is no privileged reference system tell us where we are, and ignorance of our own condition, not know any other way of life with which to compare the evolutionary scale.
• There are cognitive limits, the result of our own nature mathematical limits, which originates in the scientific and technological development, and natural boundaries, which do not depend on us.
philosophical versions of the Anthropic Principle
"Weak Anthropic Principle:
-Strong Anthropic Principle: The answer to the question why the universe is as it is? Has only one possible answer: "If it were not such as would not be here and we could not ask that question." However, according to this version, we might ask the question from any other region of the universe, for if not existiésemos in this area, we would in another because the conditions of the universe are those that are just to allow the existence of life. We can conclude that our own existence that gives meaning to the universe. This may contribute to the deification of man, and re-establish the radical anthropocentrism that was eliminated by Copernicus to the sixteenth century. Or, allow the return of the theory of Intelligent Design, which developed alongside evolutionary theories to the emergence of Darwin, and that seems to accompany the cosmology in the form of neo-Darwinism.
-Final Anthropic Principle: Defend the existence of a type of intelligent processing that there indefinitely. Has been branded as unscientific, but rather, of mystical and religious. Rescues the theory of Intelligent Design.
Conclusions
Looking at the Anthropic Principle from the perspective of critical rationalism, so fashionable, is certainly its weak version that best fits our current beliefs and accepted theories. However it may seem a way to explain really gross phenomena that physicists can not explain, because in many respects, is more a philosophical than a scientific idea, but is that physics is closely related to philosophy. In ancient times, physicists were those who occupied the posts of scientist and philosopher.
Physics uses the scientific method to explain our origins, the world we live in and the universe that contains us. Covers all scales, the atom and the galaxies, quarks and nebulae, bosons and black holes ... They seem so different, yet all are necessary for the maintenance of cosmic order. Since ancient times, the universe fascinates us with its mysterious traps us walk ... it's perfect. On a starry night is ideal lost in their deepest secrets ... It's all we can do: observing and thinking. Well, actually also interact with it, but to what extent. Are we just a contingency or otherwise are the "Holy Grail Cosmological?
consider the possibility that we are so important that our presence determines the universal sense. Before we talk about Therefore, based on the Strong Anthropic Principle, in the multiplicity of universes. Reflections on the chaotic inflation model Andrei Linde, whereby numerous spherical universes. Only some observers will be developed to endow meaning to the universe, but the probability that all physical constants to match perfectly to develop life, assuming it would be a carbon-based life, very few. So if in a universe develops an intelligent civilization, the probability that in another universe develops is 0, because no universe has the same physical constants, and only with certain Such observers may appear. We can then apply the Principle of Economy and remove lifeless universes theory. We would do the same for different regions of space is also proposed in the PAF, because if one of them and there is life and we assume it will not in others, it makes no sense there. This reduces the strong anthropic principle Weak Anthropic Principle
from the anthropocentric point of view it makes no sense that there are all the nebulae, galaxies, stars and planets, because the mere existence of the solar system and gives meaning to the universe, therefore the other celestial bodies are unnecessary. Or maybe not, because maybe there to increase the likelihood that a system appears life, because as we know there are many parameters that determine the possibilities of a given planet to host an intelligent civilization.
And if there are so many parameters, and it is so difficult that they are so well calibrated to allow our existence, why not consider the possibility of universal design, an engineer cosmic? It does not seem so outlandish if we look in the XVIII century theologian William Paley, who expounded his idea as follows in a well-known passage which marked the start of his "Natural Theology, or evidence of existence and attributes of divinity contained from aspects of nature "of 1803:
" Suppose that, when crossing a thicket, my foot stumbles upon a stone, and I wonder how you got that rock there, you could probably answer that, so I knew, had been there all along: perhaps it would not be easy to show the absurdity of this response. But suppose I had found a watch on the floor and asked me what had happened to the watch was in that place, I could not give the same answer as before, that, as far as I know, the clock could be been there ever since. [The accuracy and complexity of their design would force us to conclude] that the watch must have had a maker: that there must have been sometime and somewhere, an artificer or artificers, who built a purpose whose answer are in now, that its construction, and designed use. [No one could reasonably oppose this conclusion, since] every indication of an idea, every manifestation of design that exists in the watch, exists in the works of nature, with the difference, by the latter, to be as lofty or more , and to a degree which exceeds all computation. "
Hume, however, criticized the natural theology, and with it, Intelligent Design theory, being simply an analogy. We can establish a relationship between a clock, a car, a house ... and the universe, but this can not be used as a verification test since there are no testable similarities between objects and the cosmos above. But at that time, although atheism seemed the most logical and sensible approach, it would leave a deep intellectual dissatisfaction, because until the law came the evolution of the species of Darwin, which finally completed the atheist, the problem of irreducible complexity could not be solved.
Today, the old argument resurfaces design in the context of the anthropic principle. The universe and the fine tuning of the fundamental constants. However, the new theory of design has been removed from the logical point of view and sound of contemporary physics, which, like Darwin, he presents natural settings where the fine tuning of physical constants and parameters that govern the universe are not too important.
As we accumulate knowledge about the universe and we discover new laws of physics, the image of the intelligent designer, creator, disappears to become the hope of some to place the man in the place he has never reciprocated (anthropocentrism) In the words of Bertrand Russel:
"The believers in Cosmic Purpose up much of our supposed intelligence, but his writings make one doubt it. If I ensure the omnipotence, and millions of years to experiment with it, not think much could boast Man as an end result of all my efforts. "
Websites consulted
or http://www.astrocosmo.cl/
or http://es.wikipedia .org / wiki / Principio_antr% C3% B3pico
or http://www.pensament.com/antropico.htm
or http://www.geocities.com/CapeCanaveral/Launchpad/2921/antropico.htm
o http://www.hispaseti.org/antropico_hawking.php
o http://www.nodo50.org/arevolucionaria/masarticulos/febrero2003/principioantropico.htm
o http://www.fluvium.org/textos/cultura/cul71.htm
o http://www.espinoso.org/biblioteca/principioantropico.htm
o http://www.centrodelleculture.org/docs/ANTRO1.HTM
o http://www.filosofia-internet.net/portal/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=84
o http://personales.ya.com/casanchi/ast/cosmos1.htm
o http://www.uv.es/metode/anuario2004/13_2004.htm
o http://www.inaoep.mx/~rincon/carbono.html
o http://www.cosediscienza.it/astro/04.%20IL%20PRINCIPIO%20ANTROPICO.htm
o http://perso.wanadoo.es/josemaba/pagom1.htm
o http://www.uv.es/metode/anuario2004/11_2004.htm
o http://www.agea.org.es/content/view/99/41/
o http://web.upaep.mx/Investigaciones/cecir/ArticuloMiguel%20Gutierrez.htm
o http://www.ilustrados.com/publicaciones/EpZVAlylApaKpzPwzI.php
o http://www.todo-ciencia.com/fisica-mates/
o http://ciencia.nasa.gov/headlines/y2003/11feb_map.htm
Books consulted
or Hawking, SW, Brief History of Time. The big bang to black holes, Editorial Crítica, Barcelona.
or Heidmann, J., Life in the Universe, Alianza Editorial, Madrid.
or Greene, B., The Elegant Universe, Vintage, New York. Guide
or night sky. Astronomy, Blume, Barcelona.
or Roman, CA, Secrets of the cosmos, Salvat, Madrid. Atlas
or philosophy, Alliance Atlas, Madrid.
or Bueno.G., Hidalgo.A., Iglesias.C., Symploke. Philosophy 3 º BUP, Júcar Ediciones, Madrid.
and Reeves, H., Latest news of the cosmos. By the first second Alianza Universidad, Madrid.
0 comments:
Post a Comment